@showsiveseen Jethro Compton & @Darren Clark's "The Curious Case of Benjamin Button" #musical at the Ambassadors Theatre. A remarkable feat of talent where the actors sing, dance, *AND* accompany themselves all at the same time. Music vibes similar to @Come From Away. Funny running gag of mixed-up sayings. Starring John Dagleish. Review: showsiveseen.com/13883 Photos: Marc Brenner Musical Director: Mark Aspinall Choreo: Chi-San Howard #westEnd #BenjaminButton #theatre #musicalTheatre @Benjamin Button The Musical ♬ Shippin' Out Tomorrow – Cast of The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
Elevator Thoughts (aka Tweet): Jethro Compton & Darren Clark’s The Curious Case of Benjamin Button musical at the Ambassadors Theatre. A remarkable feat of talent where the actors sing, dance, *AND* accompany themselves all at the same time. Music vibes similar to Come From Away. Funny running gag of mixed-up sayings. Starring John Dagleish. #time
See it if you enjoy either 1) shows set in rural United Kingdom, 2) the actors playing instruments in Girl from North County, 3) or the musical style in Come From Away.
Was This the First Time I Attended a Production of this Show? Yes
Would I See It Again 3 Years from Now? No, but it was good.
Mainstream Appeal: Medium
If A Random Stranger Asked What Show They Should See This Weekend, Would I Mention This Production? Yes
My Synopsis (No Spoilers): Based on the classic short story (and possibly its film adaptation), Benjamin Button is born an old man and grows younger with time. At first, he struggles to belong in a world that cannot understand his extraordinary condition. Yet as his life unfolds in reverse, he realizes a universal truth that no matter which way the clock runs, our time is precious and should be cherished.
Synopsis from the Licensor or Theatre Company: The three-time Olivier Award-winning Best New Musical, The Curious Case of Benjamin Button, is an epic, intimate and unforgettable West End hit – hailed as “THE BEST BRITISH MUSICAL IN DECADES” (WhatsOnStage) and “A MUSICAL TO TREASURE” (The Standard). Based on the iconic short story by F. Scott Fitzgerald and reimagined in a Cornish fishing village by award-winning writing team Jethro Compton and Darren Clark, this unique, actor-musician led story is “EPIC AND CINEMATIC WITH A TREMENDOUS SCORE” (Daily Mail). Winning the 2025 Olivier Awards for Best New Musical, Outstanding Musical Contribution (Darren Clark and Mark Aspinall) and Best Actor in a Musical (John Dagleish), the 14-strong cast of actor-musicians playing 30 instruments perform “MIRACLES OF DEXTERITY ON STAGE” (The Times) – bringing to life a heart-burstingly, magical tale of a love that defies all odds. Under the light of a full moon, something most curious occurs… Benjamin Button is born old. Bound to the fate of growing younger each day, Benjamin wants nothing more than to live a little life. But will he ever find a place to belong?
Type: Musical
World Premiere: No
Several or Few Scenes: Several
Several or Few Settings/Locations: Several
Static (Stationary) or Dynamic Set: Static
Prior Exposure/Knowledge Required: If you’re familiar with the short story or the film, you might find this adaptation more accessible. But don’t expect it to follow the movie closely, as I discovered. While I’ve seen the film, I haven’t read the original story, which I suspect this musical draws from more faithfully. For instance, in the musical, Benjamin Button doesn’t begin life as an infant-sized old man, nor does he live the wide-ranging worldly life depicted on screen. His parents are also not a Black adopted couple, and the story’s tragedy diverges significantly from the film’s version.
Defined Plot/Storyline: Yes
Live Band/Orchestra: Yes, it was the entire cast
Union Actors: 14
Total Actors: 14
Perceived Pace of the Show: Medium Speed
Was there an intermission? Yes
Length (Including Any Intermission): 2.5 hours
Other Rave(s)
- Actor Band: The actors impressively doubled as their own orchestra. They played a vibrant plethora of instruments including the flute, guitar, fiddle, accordion, bass, drums, beatbox, spoons, tambourine, trumpet, piccolo, French horn, and cello. It was remarkable to watch them play the score (by Darren Clark and Mark Aspinall) entirely from memory while simultaneously acting and dancing. A production like this must be more economical than one requiring a separate band. I can only hope the performers were compensated extra for being their own orchestra.
- Running Gag: The script by Jethro Compton featured a funny running gag of botched sayings like “Just do it a hundred times and you’ll be able to do it with your mouth closed” and “There’s plenty more girls in the sea.”
- Drowning: Drowning was portrayed with striking realism and simplicity. It required no elaborate stage effects to convey its impact, just mostly lighting design (by Zoe Spurr).
- Reunion: A heartbreakingly touching reunion unfolded as Benjamin Button, appearing youthful in his later years, encountered Little Jack (played by Jack Quarton) from his earlier years who didn’t recognize him.
Rant(s)
- Unimportant Characters and Details: The script was weighed down by excessive inconsequential side characters, which distracted from the core story that the audience truly needed to follow and remember. Similarly, it overemphasized trivial details like times, dates, and minutes too often. To put it in perspective, imagine if “Seasons of Love” from Rent listed not just “five hundred twenty-five thousand six hundred minutes,” but 50 additional time references. While the intention was clearly to reinforce the theme of time, the effect was more overwhelming than meaningful.
Other Musing(s) and Observation(s)
- Folksy Tunes, Foreign Lens: Much like my previous review of Stereophonic, this show was challenging to fully connect with as a BiPOC audience member. Set in the weathered coastal countryside of the UK and steeped in folksy pub music, it’s unapologetically British in flavor. Portland, Oregon audiences would love it, especially with the rich array of instruments.
- Hollywood vs Stage Male Romantic Lead: The talented leading male actor John Dagleish brought a unique presence to the role. But he differed from the conventional Hollywood leading-man look. I had come in expecting someone more in the vein of Brad Pitt from the film!
Venue: Ambassadors Theatre
Venue Physical Address: West St, London WC2H 9ND, United Kingdom
Venue Classification: West End
Dates: October 10, 2024 to October 11, 2025
Seating: Assigned Seating
Like/Comment/Share my Social Media Posts About this Performance:
Buy a Ticket or Learn More:
Pictures: See production pictures below by Marc Brenner.
Cast and Production Team: See after pictures below.
